Customizing My Emotional Spin Cycle:

Annotated Bibliography

 

Psych 409a ---Fall 2001---G15

Dr. Leon James, Instructor

 

By Bumyong Sung
Date: 12/13/01
Instruction for this Report

 

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Overview

Emotions

Feelings

Threefold-Self

Hierachy of Needs

Citations


Overview

Everyday, all individuals experience countless feelings and emotions consciously or unconsciously. While some of these feelings and emotions are kept inside, some of them are expressed in overt behaviors. How each individual chooses which emotions to be buried and which to be expressed? If he chose which feelings to express, then what is the process of showing those feelings in actual behaviors?

This project is about customizing one’s emotional spin cycle. By studying the forces and process that affect one’s behaviors such as: environment, feelings, emotions, and thoughts, we can become more aware of emotional spin cycle- the process of feeling, thinking and doing. When we become more conscious of our emotional spin cycle, we can become better life managers of our daily lives.

This report is the first part of the project. In this report, the basic concepts, emotions, feelings, threefold of self, and hierarchy of motives, of the emotional spin cycle will be covered. However, before defining these factors, more explanations on the emotional spin cycle is necessary to understnad why these basic conceptions must be defined first.

Below is the explanation of Dr. Leon James on the emotional spin cycle.

http://www.soc.hawaii.edu/leonj/leonj/leonpsy15/g15reports-instructions.html#overview
The above figure shows the 4 zones arranged in a circle. The upper half (zones 1 and 2) refers to others (and the world) while the lower half (zones 2 and 4) refers to self. Zone 1 is the negative red zone and is called Rage. Note that the zone includes the threefold-self: Feeling habits, thinking habits, and sensori-motor habits. Zone 2 is the negative blue zone and is marked Depression--also in three types of habits. Zone 3 is the positive blue zone and is called Mastery (or Self-Confidence). It too operates in affective behaviors (feeling), cognitive behaviors (thinking), and sensori-motor behaviors (acting or doing). Zone 4 is the positive red zone and is called resolve or zeal (or Compassion). Resolve or zeal is red hot like anger but it is more rational and tolerant; hence anger is negative while resolve or zeal is positive.

As you can see, emotional spin cycle is produced based on feeling, thinking and doing which represent threefold-self. This is the term Dr. James created to explain the process that an individual goes through to process a stimulus which may be expressed through behaviors. According to Dr. James, when an individual are more awared of his own emotional spin cycle, he becomes to have more control over his life.

 

Emotion

Emotion is any state caused by motivation to seek rewards or avoid punishments. When we feel thirsty, they want something to quench our thirst such as water or soda. In other words, we are motivated to seek rewards that will satisfy our needs, water in this case. It is this kind of motivation that creates emotions. Whenever we feel any kinds of emotion, whether sadness or happiness, they are associated with rewards and punishments. We feel happy when we receive rewards, and we are sad when we receive punishment

http://www.bbsonline.org/documents/a/00/00/04/89/bbs00000489-00/bbs.rolls.html

Emotions can usefully be defined as states elicited by rewards and punishments, including changes in rewards and punishments (see also Rolls 1986a; 1986b; 1990). A reward is anything for which an animal will work. A punishment is anything that an animal will work to escape or avoid. An example of an emotion might thus be happiness produced by being given a reward, such as a pleasant touch, praise, or winning a large sum of money. Another example of an emotion might be fear produced by the sound of a rapidly approaching bus, or the sight of an angry expression on someone's face. We will work to avoid such stimuli, which are punishing. Another example would be frustration, anger, or sadness produced by the omission of an expected reward such as a prize, or the termination of a reward such as the death of a loved one. Another example would be relief, produced by the omission or termination of a punishing stimulus such as the removal of a painful stimulus, or sailing out of danger. These examples indicate how emotions can be produced by the delivery, omission, or termination of rewarding or punishing stimuli, and go some way to indicate how different emotions could be produced and classified in terms of the rewards and punishments received, omitted, or terminated.

Often these emotions contain three components. For example, when we are scared, we feel a sense of fear, then we show it through our behaviors, such as trembling or moving to a safer place which will reduce the sense of fear. One interesting part is that emotions require conscious awareness. If we are in dangerous situation but we do not actually realize it, then are we going to feel scared? Most likely, there will not be any change in our emotion until some negative stimulus affect us.

http://www.alleydog.com/descriptions.html

Emotion is such a difficult concept to define adequately that there are at least 90 different definitions of emotions in the scientific literature. A simple definition of emotion is that it is a response by a whole organism, involving (1) physical arousal, (2) expressive behaviors, and (3) conscious experience. As you can see from this definition, emotions contain both physical and mental components, and require conscious awareness. I guess one can ask, "if a person is happy, but does not realize that he or she is happy, is that person really happy?"

So far, all the definitions of emotion listed above seems to suggest that all emotions are necessary to survive. Therefore, one can say acting out emotions are good and all justified. Imagin, what would happen if you do not feel any sense of thirst even though you are dehydrated that you are about to die? What about a sense of fear? Isn't it really necessary when you are in situations like walkng alone on the street at night? The problem is that these emotions often bring catastrophic results.

http://www.drnerenberg.com/people.htm

In Salt Lake City, after a fender bender, one driver guns her engine and runs over the other - fatally.  In Santa Cruz, Calif., a man who tailgated is shot dead by the offended tailgatee.  In Massachusetts, a driver flashes his high beams at another motorist.  When the two come to a stop, the slower driver steps out of his car and fatally wounds the would-be passer with a crossbow.

Above incidents are the results of people who acted out their emotions that they experienced on the road. When we see the incidents like these, it is not hard to realize that expressing emotions can be dangerous and we should think about consequences of our behaviors.

 

Feelings

 

Feelings are any reaction that humans make to stimuli that they experience. It could be external such as being hit by a ball or could be internal such as feelings of abandonment.

http://www.forthelittleonesinside.com/mpage/feelings.html

"Feelings are a natural part of being human, living in a body. They come in response to our inner and outer experiences of the present moment, in response to memories of past experiences evoked by/in the present moment and, often, in response to our anticipation of moments yet to come

Although feelings and emotions are interchangeable, they are different. Feeling is detached sense such as mere awareness, consciousness, and attention while emotion is more like attached and meaningful feelings that are sensational.

http://www.astromind.com/articles/definition_of_mind.html

How is feeling not an emotion?

But what is feeling? There is a difference between feeling and emotion; they are not the same thing. You can feel an emotion but you can't emotion a feel. Feeling is detached observation. It's the ability to notice and witness a particular experience in a dispassionate way without intellectual or emotional involvement, attachment, or reaction. Feeling is a cooperative effort between your attention, consciousness, and awareness, and is sometimes associated with the realm of spirit. If matter is objective and mind is subjective then spirit must be collective, right? Think about it a little and you will see the connection.

http://www.astromind.com/articles/experience.html

http://www.geocities.com/Athens/Ithaca/2911/music.html

"Sadness, anger, physical or emotional attraction (often called love), jealousy, bubbling over with mirth -they are all emotions. They can be pleasant or unpleasant, but they all make us restless. Feelings, like spiritual love, compassion and joy, are different. They can exist in a peaceful mind."

The second citation is from one of the former students of a driving psychology class. According to him, feeling is something exists in a peaceful mind. I agree with him. Incidents occur when people become emotional. Emotions often include judgements and interpretations, not logical but emotional interpretations. Then, emotions take over and buries humans from its rationality.

THE ROLE OF INTERPRETATIONS

Often your feelings are related to your interpretations of events more than to the events themselves. While it is natural to think that you are responding only to the events of your life, in fact you make interpretations or judgments of these events, and these interpretations play a key role in your emotional responses. When you stop to think about it, each event could yield a variety of emotional responses; your interpretation of the event helps link a particular emotional response to that event.

Consider the following diagram (adapted from Ellis, 1962):

Event

--------------------> Interpretation   --------------------> Emotional
Response

Threefold-Self

The basic of the emotional spin cycle is based on the threefold-self concept. The threefold–self refers an individual’s feeling, thinking, and acting. According to Dr. James, these three parts function together although not every feelings or thoughts are expressed in overt behaviors.

http://www.soc.hawaii.edu/leonj/leonj/leonpsy15/g15reports-instructions.html

"All individuals are socialized in accordance with cultural norms. To be socialized means to acquire particular habits in the three areas of human functioning:

? habits of feeling (AFFECTIVE DOMAIN OF BEHAVIOR)

? habits of thinking (COGNITIVE DOMAIN OF BEHAVIOR)

? habits of acting (SENSORI-MOTOR DOMAIN OF BEHAVIOR)

Every individual has a threefold-self in which the three parts function together, yet each can be distinguished and isolated for observation and self-modification.

The threefold-self has two arenas to function in. One is the arena of "others" (or the world out there), and the second is the arena of "self." These two arenas--Others and Self--each require their own particular way of functioning. The arena of others is referred to as "the red zone" and the arena of self as "the blue zone." Every day individuals have to function in both zones since they have to deal with others (red zone) and with oneself (blue zone).

The following excerpt from former student of Dr. James Leon explains the threefold concept really well. According to this article, the two domains, cognitive and sensorimotor stem from the initial domain, feeling. Also, the article claims that when people are aware of this three-step process, people can accomplish a behavior modification.

http://www.soc.hawaii.edu/leonj/409af99/mazza/report1.html

A major principle of Traffic Psychology is the Three Domains of Driving Behavior. The three following domains envelop driving behavior: the Affective, the Cognitive, and the Sensorimotor. The Affective domain pertains to an individual's feelings and motivations. I think this is the most important domain. Your brain and it's thinking process control every thing that you do, including your behaviors during driving. Learning to maintain the motive of avoiding driving errors is an important Affective driving skill. When a person does not think of this, he will become a sloppy driver, and possibly cause an accident. Someone's feelings of wanting to be cautious and law abiding are weakened by the feeling of urge to hurry and not be too late. The more things on ones mind, the more difficult it is to focus. The Cognitive domain involves the judgement or thoughts that an individual has. This domain stems from the affective. The driver processes information by common sense logic. For example, in a certain driving situations, a person needs to make important decisions on what to do, the cognitive process controls this (whether or not it will be the right decision). The Sensorimotor domain is comprised of the individual's sensory inputs (vison, sounds) and motor output (actions). From turning the wheel to breathing, this domain is in charge of monitoring any physical action that is caused by the other two domains. These Three Domains of Driving Behavior need to be attended to individually in order to achieve a behavior modification.

The below is one of the experiment that is conducted by a former student. Each domain of emotional spin cycle is clearly explaind in this article. The conductor’s boyfriend is being strictly monitored for the purpose of experiment. She did a good job of recording his behavior and categorizing into the three domains.

http://www.soc.hawaii.edu/leonj/409bf99/barr/report2.html#4

Affective: His attitude was surprisingly positive and he let me know that he would cooperate as much as possible. I can definitely say he told the truth because every time I corrected him, he complied passively. I do think that a large part of his pleasant feelings arose from the way I set up day 2. This put him in a positive frame of mind and I also asked him to think ahead of time about what he could do during rough periods, especially since I already knew we had serious construction to deal with. Cognitive: This trip was not really the time for him to express his thoughts, it was my turn and he found it a little amusing to listen to my thought processing, for example: "I think it would be better if you followed the car in front of us with two car lengths between us, rather than half of a foot". He believed I was right and did so without any hesitation. Sensorimotor: He continued to be courteous when allowing other people to merge in front of him with hand gestures and waves to those that did the same for him. I had put on some relaxing classical music, and I think this also helped because he did not seem to be as tense as the day before. Again I credit my preparations for this day. Which allows me to conclude that there was bias to this experiment and maybe it would weaken if I repeated the "pleasant" driving instructions everyday.

When we are not aware of threefold self process, situations like below can happen. According to Dr. James Leon, we all should realize that there is dragon in each of us, which will just consume everything in rage.

http://www.soc.hawaii.edu/leonj/leonj/459s97/lagunoy/lagunoyreport1.html

" Slay Your Driving Dragon" Here, Dr. Driving tells us how we can determine if we have a dragon within ourselves. For instance, here are some of the examples he mentioned. You have a dragon if: **You enjoy calling other drivers obscenities. **You 'like' to take on the responsibility of teaching other drivers how to 'really' drive. Show them all how to drive, since you think you're such an expert. An expert at getting into accidents, getting tickets, getting scratches on you car, etc..... Dr. Driving says that if you have a dragon, it must be killed. To have a dragon is bad, not to have a dragon is good. Although some of us enjoy being an aggressive type driver, it's wise and much more safer to be a passive-type drive. To kill the dragon, is to save the lives of other drivers. Personally, I like being an aggressive type driver. However, I admit, I've been in some close calls. Where in my mind I ask the other driver, "Where'd you get your license from, 'Cracker Jacks'!" Hump, but I guess Dr. Driving is right.

The article above shows well that when we are aware of our threefold-self process, we can change our negative behaviors. However, most of time, we are unconscious of this process and create hostile situations like a lady who vents her rage toward her husband. Again, by naming true emotions and becoming more aware of threefold self, detrimental situations like below can be avoid.

http://www.oprah.com/tows/pastshows/tows_1999/tows_past_19991005.jhtml

Kari is normally outgoing and bubbly, but behind closed doors she explodes in rages so intense they sometimes last two or three days. She's even told her husband - a firefighter - that she hopes he dies in a fire. Like Shirley's husband, Kari's husband says her episodes of fury are driving him to divorce court.

Controlling the Uncontrollable
Dr. Phil believes uncontrollable rages like that experienced by Shirley and Kari (pictured at left) are only uncontrollable once they're set into motion. Otherwise, anger like theirs is "a disorder of choice." Stress is no excuse either. Dr. Phil says, "If you don't have stress, you're not alive." In short, Dr. Phil believes, "When people rage, it's because they don't have the courage to give their true emotions a voice." Those true emotions are fear, frustration, hurt and sadness. Which fuel your anger? For more information on managing your anger, visit the page for
Dr. Phil's last appearance

.Hierarchy of Needs

The emotional spin cycle, which has three domains, affective, cognitive and sensorimotor habits, is closely related to motivation-motiviation to saftisfy one's emotional needs. Emotion is any reaction that human makes toward any stimulus. No matter what kind of emotions we have, there is a motivation to satisfy needs underneath the surface. According to Maslow’s of hierarchy of needs, there are different types of needs that all humans seek to satisfy.

http://www.selfhelpmagazine.com/articles/internet/eatlife.html

We psychologists have long thought about why people become obsessed. There are a variety of theories on the topic. One common denominator is the idea that people become preoccupied with a thing, person, or activity because it satisfies a NEED. Humans are complex beings, and so the needs that fuel their behavior are complex and many. In the 1960s, Abraham Maslow, one of the founders of humanistic psychology, charted the wide variety of human needs according to a hierarchy ranging from very fundamental, biological needs to higher order ones of an aesthetic and self-actualizing nature. When a person is able to satisfy needs at one level, she is then prepared to move upward to the next. Perhaps, to answer the riddle posed by the Palace substitution script, we should take a similar path. By starting at the bottom of Maslow's hierarchy and working our way up, we can attempt to place some words around and onto that PalaceThing that can be so captivating, consuming, and delightful (BTW, I should add that some of these explanations apply to MANY chat, newsgroup, and MOO environments on the net).

Part of the reason people get mad when they stuck in traffic is because they are wasting time in the car. When we are wasting our time waiting, we are not satisfying our need to be productive. According to this article, we are taught to be productive all the time that we do not really care about our emotional well being.

http://askmen.com/fashion/body_and_mind/1_better_living.html

We simply do not put high value on relaxation. We evaluate ourselves more on measurable things such as personal achievements and financial worth -- not emotional wellness. We often tend to feel guilty if we aren't constantly being productive. This sense of guilt usually arises from our parents' pre-adolescent brainwashing. They taught us to achieve and perform; to continuously strive to become Superman. I know what you're thinking: "Yeah well, I do sometimes have problems unwinding, but it's not going to kill me."

The following article is about two Piaget and Kohlberg who studied moral development of children. I decided to put this article because it made me think what moral stage I am usually in when I drive on the road. Also, it made me think would I behave the same way if some children or strangers were with me. I think most of time, I am in the Individualism stage where I am focusing only to meet my need. One interesting aspect is that people often take a position of wrong form of high morality. For example, many aggressive drivers think they are doing good for the society by punishing other drivers who drive "slowly". It is misinterpreted moral development.

http://www.selfhelpmagazine.com/articles/child_behavior/moraldevchild.html

Two noteworthy individuals, Jean Piaget and Lawrence Kohlberg, studied the moral development of children. Piaget looked at how children develop moral reasoning. He found that young children have a much more primitive understanding of right and wrong behavior than do older children. "Who's Naughtier?" Piaget determined that younger children judge bad behavior by the amount of damage caused by a person's behavior. He would tell children a story with a moral dilemma. He would ask them to tell him "who is naughtier:" a boy who accidentally broke fifteen cups or a boy who breaks one cup trying to reach a jam jar when his mother is not around. Younger children attributed the "naughty" behavior to the boy who broke the most cups regardless of the other child's intent. This type of moral reasoning was called Objective Morality or Moral Realism. Older children attributed bad behavior to the boy who broke only one cup because his motives where bad. This, more advanced form of moral reasoning was called Subjective Morality or Autonomous Morality. Piaget did not feel that children fully achieved this stage of moral development before the ages of twelve or thirteen. "What's Right?" Kohlberg carried Piaget's work into adolescence and adulthood. He also told children moral dilemma stories, but he would ask them to tell him what they thought would be the right thing to do. Their answers led him to the discovery of three levels of moral development with two stages each: The first level is called Preconventional. During this level children are concerned with avoiding punishment (Stage 1: Punishment-Obedience) and getting one's own needs met (Stage 2: Individualism). This level and its stages fit into the framework of young children, up to the age of ten years. The second level is called Conventional. During this level children are more concerned with living up to the expectations of others (Stage 3: Interpersonal Conformity) and want to do the right thing because it is good for the group, family, or institution (Stage 4: Social System and Conscience). This level and its stages fit children over the age of ten years and on to adulthood. The third level is called Postconventional. During this level individuals govern their behavior by the relative values and opinions of the groups they live and interact with. Right behavior is based on a "social contract" (Stage 5: Social Contract and Individual Rights) with others and in the validity of universal moral principles (Stage 6: Universal/Ethical Principles) which may or may not agree with societies laws. Laws that agree with universal moral principles are obeyed but when those laws violate these principles, the individual follows the principles instead.

The top portion of the hierarchy of motive is related to values. The article below is written after an interview with Howard Gardner. Although he does not mention about the emotional spin cycle or morality, I chose this article because he claims no matter how much knowledge we have, it does not become effective, until we embody our knowledge into our daily lives. Incorporating our values to our everyday lives is the hardest yet essential process that we all need to improve on.

http://www.strategy-business.com/thoughtleaders/99109/page1.html

In order for a story to be effective in the long run, though, it must be "embodied." The individual or institution that bears the narrative must behave consistently with it. Because if you tell one story but you live another -- if you don't walk the talk, to use the vernacular -- then the story doesn't have appeal.

If you're a very good embodier, though, you don't have to be such a good storyteller because your symbolic behavior really conveys the point. That's interesting in the corporate sense because the more you're trying to create a new business, or change a business radically, the more important is the story you tell. But for an organization that's very well launched, where the story is quite set and you don't need to change it -- as in the Army or the Catholic Church -- it is only important that you embody the story.

People do some unimaginable things when they drive. It is like they are becoming totally different people. Some psychologists say it is because the car provides different surrounding. After all, we are operating heavy metal made machine, and we feel protected or even invincible.

However, whether we feel invincible or not, we should realize the consequence of our action. Like a teenager boy in this article, when rage is carried over to the action, catastrophic consequences can happen.

http://www.soc.hawaii.edu/leonj/leonj/459f96/scarbrou/report1.html

Many people really don't think traffic psychology is important however if we look at the past you will see that traffic accidents are one of the leading causes of deaths and injuries. The cost of car insurance has gone up because of traffic accidents, this has become an economic worry for many Americans. Looking at all of this depressing information, we have to realize that traffic psychology is important.

My opinion is that traffic psychology is important, and not just because of the economic costs, and accidents, but also for the sake of our own mental well being. Driving can be very stressful if you let it get to you. Who knows what we are capable of doing? A good example is the tragic death of an off duty officer in October. According to the newspaper an alleged traffic confrontation between the off duty officer and a 17 year old man led to the death of the officer. According to witnesses the two men pulled over on the freeway to argue and, the 17 year old man with no prior history of arrests pushed the officer off a freeway viaduct. Unfortunately the officer did not survive the fall and the young man was arrested, and is now waiting for trial. We can all learn from this as well as many other types of similar incidents that traffic psychology is important. I think traffic psychology should be included in drivers education in high schools as well as drivers education in the judicial system.

Citations

Generational Curriculum

"Report 1-Traffic Psychology." Internet. 20Oct2001Available:
http://www.soc.hawaii.edu/leonj/409af99/mazza/report1.html

"Being a Driving Buddy." Internet. 20Oct2001 Available:
http://www.soc.hawaii.edu/leonj/409bf99/barr/report2.html#4

"Lesson in Driving Etiquette." Internet. 20Oct2001 Available:
http://www.soc.hawaii.edu/leonj/leonj/459s97/lagunoy/lagunoyreport1.html

"Definition of Traffic Psychology." Internet. 20Oct2001 Available:
http://www.soc.hawaii.edu/leonj/leonj/459f96/scarbrou/report1.html

"General Instruction for your research project." Internet.17Oct2001 Available:
http://www.soc.hawaii.edu/leonj/leonj/leonpsy15/g15reports-instructions.html

 

News Media

"Opera’s 2000 Time Capsule". Internet. 19Oct2001 Available:
http://www.oprah.com/tows/pastshows/tows_1999/tows_past_19991005.jhtml

"Why is This Thing Eating My Life?". Internet. 18Oct2001 Available:
http://www.selfhelpmagazine.com/articles/internet/eatlife.html

"Dealing with Stress." Internet. 21Oct2001 Available:
http://askmen.com/fashion/body_and_mind/1_better_living.html

"Moral Development of Children" Internet. 17Oct2001 Available:
http://www.selfhelpmagazine.com/articles/child_behavior/moraldevchild.html

"An Interview with Howard Gardner." Internet. 18Oct2001 Available :
http://www.strategy-business.com/thoughtleaders/99109/page1.html

"Make Their Day". Internet. 15Dec2001 Available:
http://www.drnerenberg.com/people.htm

 

Websites and Article

 

"Précis of "The Brain and Emotion" for BBS multiple book review." Internet. 31Sep2001 Available
http://www.bbsonline.org/documents/a/00/00/04/89/bbs00000489-00/bbs.rolls.html

"Description of Psychology/Section/Topin. Internet." 19Oct2001 Available.:
http://www.alleydog.com/descriptions.html

"Safe for Feeling. Internet." 29Sep2001 Available:
http://www.forthelittleonesinside.com/mpage/feelings.html

"What is the mind. Internet."16Oct2001 Available:
http://www.astromind.com/articles/definition_of_mind.html

"Spirituality is. Internet."19Oct2001 Available.
http://www.geocities.com/Athens/Ithaca/2911/music.htm

" Experiencing and Expressing Emotion" Internet. October 10, 2001.Available
http://www.couns.uiuc.edu/Brochures/Emotions.htm

 

 

The Class Home Page My Home Page