|
The Mercurial Mind in Cyber-Space |
|
Table of Contents |
|
Almost and essentially authentic but not quite there formally. This is to some extent a literal explanation, however, how does it apply to cyberspace? In cyberspace, we are experiencing a new world that is in essence real, deemed virtual reality. This world is mostly formed by communication of thoughts from the minds of many individuals, thus making it a gathering of minds focused mostly on the cognitive and affective aspects of life. There are many similarities between brain/computer and mind/cyberspace and I will touch on these in the next section, "The Relationship between Cyberspace and Mind." Also to be noted in further reports on this page, Sherry Turkle, a sociology professor at MIT, finds much simulation of life in the regions of computerized medium, whether it be a game, educational CD-ROM, Tamagochi toy or cyberspace. Simulation of reality is, of course, only a depiction or imitation of reality and not actually real. At this point, some ancient philosophical ideas could possibly shed some light on the issue of virtual reality. Plato, in his Cave analogy, expressed different levels in which individuals are conscious of the world in which they live. At each level the individual believes s/he is experiencing that which is real. The lowest level of consciousness is the level of images. This is the simulation of life, certainly not the real thing -- like a movie. The second level is that of physical objects: the actual physical, material world. These first two levels are both of the physical plane. The next two levels are of the mind or psyche. Level three is the world of mathematical ideas: it is here that one realizes a world beyond the physical but yet still relates to the physical. And, finally there is the level of ideals: thought forms, spiritual concepts, other worldly, non-material. Ultimately, one is brought to the pinnacle of The Good. This level to Plato was that of the truth, the actual, the real. How does this analogy relate to virtual reality? It appears that the participation of an individual in cyberspace can be at any one level or all four levels at the same time. For example, on the first level of images, a person could immerse himself in a false identity in a Multi User Domain (MUD) room. Here he could spend a significant part of his life and create his personality, social status, livelihood and even gender to be completely different than in real life (IRL). He could convince himself that in the MUD his real identity exists: who he really is is expressed online. However, MUD's are only games, and these games are at best a simulation of life. If he can not maintain the same personality et.al in the physical world, then, no matter how much his ego wants to be the MUD person, it is not really him. A second level example would be wherein one is conscious of the physical distinctions (person and computer) and pragmatically use the computer as a tool to accomplish business, communication, research or even play games. This person recognizes the material value of computers and the internet but has no concept of anything beyond the practical use of a machine. He may play a game in a MUD room, however, his identity there would only be pretend and he knows it. He could, nevertheless, practice a new behavior in the MUD room and, if he likes the results, apply it IRL and then he would know it is his. The third level of mathematical concepts can be illustrated with the example of a person who understands the logical, mathematical, electronic workings of a computer and its relation to cyberspace. In a MUD room, this person would be more interested in manipulating programs and working complexity into his room and character, perhaps creating a BOT. And, finally at the fourth level, would be an individual interested in the philosophical mind to mind relationships, the spiritual concepts of cyberspace and all the creative and expansive potentialities involved. On this level one could experience concepts of mind by contemplating the experience of communal mind. Of course, most people will operate on all levels at the same time, however, one level would probably dominate. Also, it can only exist through participation of individuals and can never be all of life hence, its virtual realness. |
|
|
|
Understanding the mind is like holding on to a drop of mercury: as soon as you think you have it, it slips away. There is much to be said about the relationship between cyberspace and mind. We create in our own image and we perceive what we create to be that of our own image. It is all we are able to do. As the mind and brain work together, computers and cyberspace work together. Cyberspace is in its infancy and as much as an infant's mind is free and filters are not yet established to weed out unwanted stimulants, so to is cyberspace. Cyberspace is free, practically unfiltered and expression of thought and feelings are anonymous, uncensored and numerous. I predict this will not continue for long. Search engines, for example, have a position of organizing the access to different sites on the internet and, as such, have a position of control which up to this point has been manageable for them. Just as a child develops and more concepts need to be categorized and organized in his mind, the more overwhelming cyberspace becomes, the more organizing and filtering will most likely occur. Nevertheless, until things change, how people behave online can give us insight as to how people think without the guards of censorship. How strong are one's ethics, values and /or social kindness when temptations are presented without the consequences? As people behave with pretension online, are we creating a culture based on conning each other? The anonymity and privacy of the internet in certain respects seems to allow people who would normally censor certain thoughts and feelings to express them. How this affects our culture and society remains to be seen. In a class discussion, I mentioned that the current stage of cyberspace
is similar to the "Wild West" where consequences for actions
were few. Many people behaved lawlessly and got away with it. The freedoms
presented at that time also created freer thinking and innovations in living.
In cyberspace this freedom exists now but already laws are being developed
to prevent abuses such as theft, child pornography and the like. (Some
students in class opposed my prediction that the internet would not remain
as free as it is for long, however, check out this site Another aspect of the relationship
between cyberspace and mind is how it can effect change in an individual.
As James Sempsey, Ph.D.. states in
Dr. Sempsey also discusses the importance
of learning in our evolutionary tract. Most scientists are stating that
we may have come to the pinnacle of our biological evolution, however,
as Dr. Sempsey points out sociologically we still evolve and the mechanism
that allows us to do this is our ability to learn. Cyberspace provides
grand opportunities for social interaction and individual growth and change.
It is also, surprisingly to some, a place where one can not run away from
oneself. John Suler, Ph.D.., explains in
One student, Leslie Francis, stated, in her generational report that I reviewed, "It is amazing to me that my thoughts on the subject were echoed by another -- let alone that I FOUND the article in the first place!" If one understands a little bit about how the mind works, it is not as surprising as it is revealing. In many ways, cyberspace is very much like the minds of those participating. In essence, what comes from a non-physical realm, the mind, transfers
thoughts and feelings through the brain, into a computer which puts these
thoughts and feelings back out into a non-physical realm - cyberspace.
Certainly, there is opportunity for psychologists to study the development
of cyberspace as it relates to the mind in a sense that it may be the closest
tool that can be used as a reflection of the mind and how it works. It
is not surprising that, what we created as a tool to use for thought work,
would be fashioned after our own brain and mind. Already, scientists
are researching how to make hypertext work more like synapses in the brain.
There are many other ways in which the mind and cyberspace relate, one
final way that I will review is that of cyberspace's similarity to the
collective unconscious. Just as Ms. Francis found echoes of her ideas
in cyberspace, I too found others who related cyberspace to the collective
unconscious. In John Suler's ongoing forum, |
|
There were a number of facinating
sites that I found in relation to the subject of Cyber-Psychology.
The author of Life on the Screen, Sherry Turkle Ph.D.has been interviewed
quite often. Dr. John Suler has a This There are many sites for actual psychological services on-line here
are a few samples: I hope this helps in your search for topics on cyberpsychology. If you
need more help try |
|
Four excellent generational reports can be found with the following: |
|
Dr. Leon James'
article, His next subjects cover the topics of cyberspace in its relation to mind and virtual reality. He points out that some feel threatened by the growing presence of cyberspace due to the lack of face to face contact. However, he suggests that even though a person is immensed in the computer, the great desire to communicate is the motivating factor. He goes on to express that, "computers are convenient and powerful extensions of the human mind." Dr. James goes on to explain that like the mind, cyberspace as a virtual reality has no physical form or mass. It is through interactivity that it exists. He compares two aspects of likeness between mind and cyberspace: interactivity and organization: Minds interact through organized content. That is, our mind communicates with other minds and the content of the exchange is organized by topic and by attitudes towards the topic. Cyberspace is made up of topics and access doors to these topics... Cyberspace is in effect the communal mind. This communal mind, Dr. James explains, is created through the linking process which is not and can not be owned by anyone. Ownership does, however, exist in the, "hardware, the copyrighted software, or the intellectual property rights to textual and audiovisual creations." In the overwhelmingly
vast expanse of cyberspace, people do come together and form communities
based on a certain topic, a mutual intention or some sort of common interest.
These communities form by people navigating through the Web in search of
these common interests. Navigation on the Web is made possible, as noted
above, by hypertext. URL's are used to link one site with another. Dr.
James states that while it is possible to draw a map of the Internet, it
is as impossible to chart a map of cyberspace as it is to map out the mind.
Cyberspace and the mind are both non-physical, unlimited in size and shape
whereas the brain and the Internet are both limited in size and shape.
(An interesting site to view concepts of maps of the Internet is located
here Another analogy Dr. James calls "The Virtual Book," wherein, each page is linked through the table of contents made up of hypertext. A virtual electronic library exists that is unlimited and continually growing. Herein too is a representation of the, "communal mind which is vast in comparison to the individual's mind." Further on, Dr. James explains that when one begins the process of creating a Web page, there are three basic properties that are of importance: appearance, content and access. Just as we are IRL, appearance takes on initial importance. However, if there is no substance to the content then interest in the page will soon wane. And, as any commercial realtor would say "location, location, location," in cyberspace it's "access, access, access." After explaining the basic concepts of the mind and cyberspace relations, Dr. James goes on to explore the spiritual connection to virtual reality. He proposes that the act of clicking on a link is a spiritual act in and of itself. His explanation for this is thus: The term 'psyche' contains both mind and spirit. Interests and intentions are mind and spirit driven so that action taken due to interests and intentions (such as clicking on a hypertext link) is a spiritual one. By clicking on a link, one is creating a presence in virtual reality and thus keeps up its existence. By making conscious choices on what to click, one is performing moral, ethical, economic and psychological acts. Dr. James continues to explain that while methods are being developed to filter out or block clicking, it would behoove us to develop self-witnessing and self-modification within ourselves in order to create freedom in choice that is educated and from love. |
| X
My
4 Favorites from the Online Generational Curriculum
X My First Report: How Music Affects Driving X Report on Chapter 9: Life on the Screen by Sherry Turkle, Virtuality & Its Discontents X Report on the Psychology of Newsgroups X Bookmarks File |
XMy
Home Page XClass Home Page XIndex of all Reports XDr. Leon James Home Page |