Summery:
What I got out of this E-mail
exchange was that music or lack of music definitely has an effect on us
as humans and therefore how we drive. There are three perspectives
that I found from this posting. First there was the support for the
theory that music does influence our driving. Then are the positive aspects
of music, the negative aspects of music on driving.
Does Music effect our driving?
There are proponents to both
sides. Though it heavily leans to the side that agrees that music
does affect our driving there were a few comments that suggest music does
not effect us while driving.
Positive
Some participants of this
e-mail discussion state their opinion that they believe listening to music
benefits them in their driving. They take the stand that if loud,
fast music will help cause you to drive fast and/or more aggressive, then
just the opposite will be true for slow, mellow music .
Negative
Other take the side that music
increases their aggressiveness while driving. For instance, Mr.Sasabe
blames both of his speeding tickets on his listening to music which he
claims distracted him from his driving.
The main issues that I came across in this exchange were music's effect on our concentration, music's increase or decrease of our aggressiveness.
My reaction to these idea's
is mixed. I think that music's affect varies according to individual
differences: therefore, it is not possible to say its either negative or
positive. Its just the individuals reaction to music.
For myself I know how music
affects me. Fast music will increase my tendency to drive fast and
possible more aggressive, but at the same time I am a much more content
driver if I have music in my car. In other words I am much more polite
and easy-going if there is some music while I'm driving. Its when
I do not have music that I become frustrated and then turn my aggressions
out-ward on other drivers.
As a young child and in high
school, I went through many long commutes. There would be lots of
us in one van or car, late in the day, after a long day at school and practice.
It was hard to keep a good attitude in this situation, but music seemed
to help us. Either there would be songs that we all enjoyed, or some
familiar mellow music that would put us to sleep. I think this could
be a large reason for my interest in music in the car today.
I can honest say that I would
not consider owning a car without some form of music. If I did buy
a car without a stereo, it would not be very long before I installed one.
Internet
Findings
What I found on the web was
mostly advertisements. The majority of my search was learning
about new cars and stereo products for cars.
Thought it was interesting it was not what I was looking for.
There was one site that talked
about driving laws and they were very against the laws restricting
music levels for individuals cars. They
had a biased point of view because of the fact they were against
most any law related to driving including speed
limits, type of car and exhaust restrictions.
Hands On Music,
Inc. This site provides a new theory on
music for the automobile and its
close quarters. It is a company that is
going to specialize in making driving music (music
that will sound especially good in cars).
The CSS Engine provided me with many reports that
had topics on music and driving. However,
the reports that were provided were not only
on music and driving, but I was able to find 1 report
that had information I was searching for.
REPORT #1
Braden Kato from Generation 2
In his report, Braden briefly discusses how music
can affect driving behavior. He states that some
people tend to drive more aggressively while
listening to heavy metal music. Whereas easy listening
music tend to be more relaxing for most drivers.
He also states that a person's driving personality
could be synonymous with their driving style.
Moreover, a person's driving personality is affected
by different elements, and no two driving experiences
are alike.
The Three Step Program to Regain Control at the
Wheel According to Dr. Driving:
adamant that you are out of control
witness yourself being out of control
modify your driving personality one step
at a time
Rothe
The Rothe text from Psychology 459 did not tell
me much. The main idea was just to be aware and be careful when driving.
Music did fall under on aspect for thing that can disrupt the driver.
The author mainly suggest being aware of the effects of music while driving
and then make the proper adjustments.
References
Barbara E. Schmidt, Charles P. Listeners' Response
to Music as a Function of
Personality Type. Journal of Research in Music
Education; v39 n4 p311-21 Win 1991.
Ballard, Mary E.,Coates, Steven. The Immediate
Effects of Homicidal, Suicidal, and
Nonviolent Heavy Metal and Rap Songs on the Moods
of College Students. Youth &
Society; v27 n2 p148-68 Dec 1995 .
Catton. Aspects we do not see in Driving. Changing Societies. v2 198-199 1992
Farrow, J.A. Driving While Intoxicated. Journal
of alcohol and Drug Education. v34 n2 p21-32
Win 1988
Jakobovits, L.A. Repetition of auditorily presented
information. Psychological Reports, 1965, 17,
785-86.
Lehtonen, Kimmo; Shaughnessy, Michael F.. Music
as a Treatment Channel of Adolescent
Destructivity. Video
1994
Lester, David; Whipple, Melissa. Music Preference,
Depression, Suicidal
Preoccupation, and Personality: Comment on Stack
and Gundlach's Papers. Suicide and
Life Threatening Behavior; v26 n1 p68-70 Spr
1996 .
Miller, Marilyn A. The Effects of Music Videos
on Adolescent Meaning Construction
and Attitudes toward Physical Violence as a Method
of Conflict Resolution.
Strasburger, Victor. Adolescents and the Media:
Medical and Psychological Impact. Developmental
Clinical Psychology and Psychiatry. v33
Wass, Hannelore. Adolescent and destructive Themes
in Rock Music. omega: Journal of Death
and Dying, v23 n3 pp199-206 1991
Student
Comparison
Most other students did not do this report because it was rather long and
had many parts. The student s reports that I did look at were all
good and some of them made me want to do a different one. This was
my hardest part of this class and it took by far the longest.
Conclusion
In my opinion it the responsibility of each person
to know and understand how music all aspects
of driving effect themselves. This includes music. I think
its up to the individual to know how different
kind of music could influence their driving.
I doubt that many people have taken music's influence
on their driving, seriously. I think this show that there are very
many aspects of driving that have to be taken into consideration when you
are behind the wheel. I am sure that many people take for granted
the many of factors that we face while driving.