Fast vs. Slow Music While Driving
The majority feels
that fast music causes aggressive driving. Music such as heavy metal, rock,
and the Top Gun theme were associated with feelings of excitement, a faster
heart rate, and rising blood pressure. I too believe that faster,
harder music makes drivers more anxious on the roadways. This in
turn could cause incidents of Road Rage being that those listening to faster
music seem to have less patience with other slower drivers. However; this
type of music may seem helpful for someone who works the graveyard shift
and has had just 2 hours rest prior to working an 8 hour shift.
Slow music, it seems
, tends to calm most of the participants of this email discussion while
behind the wheel. Classical, and slow methodical music such as instrument
melodies and natural sounds of rain calm the nerves of the majority of
these driver's. It seems that the soothing, soft sounds allow the driver's
to disassociate themselves from other more aggressive drivers and traffic
congestion. One writer said that slow music could make her sleepy. I agree
that slow music does calm a driver thus, they are more willing to let other
driver's in at an on ramp, and allow pedestrians to cross at intersections
without revving their engines to make them move quicker. However;
I feel that longer drives like from Makapu'u to Wai'anae would cause drivers
to daze off and get drowsy when exposed to too much slow music. I
believe slow music tends to put drivers into a trance on longer journey's
thus, the higher potential for an accident because the person listening
to soft music is not giving their full attention to the roadway and other
drivers.
Music Off While Driving
Some opinions
express feelings of spirituality and meditative states when the music in
their cars is off. Radio disc jockeys seem to annoy some people which
makes them more uncomfortable while driving this could then lead to a negative
effect on their driving behaviors. Their solution? Turn the radio
off. Another view is if a person is feeling irritated and uptight
that music just adds fuel to the fire thus, the music is usually turned
off to prevent tailgating, lane switching and other aggressive driving
behaviors. I believe if the radio is off one has the ability to concentrate
more on the actions of driver's in close proximity such as cars darting
back and forth between lanes and people riding the bumper.
I also feel that no music may often cause driver's minds to wander off
as well. Some driver's start to think about the bad day they had
at work, the rent that's due and little things like is that bird dudu on
my hood. These distracting thoughts may cause you to lose attentiveness
toward the car that just braked 10 feet in front of you while
your traveling at 45 mph down the freeway.
Listening to Favorite Songs
Wilfred Lee's email
message consisted of the idea to eliminate Road Rage with music a person
enjoys. Wilfred made a tape for his friend commutes from Pearl
City to UH Manoa for school. His theory was that by listening to
songs he enjoyed the friend would forget about the pressures of traffic
thus, alleviating the tendencies of Road Rage. Wonderful idea and
very helpful friend in my eyes; Although there was no conclusion to this
story about whether it worked or not the idea is still very promising.
I know from personal experience that a long, traffic filled commute is
much more pleasant when I am not distracted with musical tunes that aggravate
me.
My Relationship With Music and Cars
As a child music in
the car seemed like a comforting way of dealing with an hour long drive.
I would often fall asleep to soft music I liked and I would show facial
expressions of digest when my parents played an old relic tune from the
sixties. I remember riding with my Brother-in-law as a child and
watching as he would bobb his head back and forth to the blearing rock
music from the tape deck, while tapping both hands on the steering
wheel like he was playing the drums or imitating Jimi Hendrix playing
the guitar with his teeth, and all the while controlling the vehicle
with his left knee raised just under the steering wheel (very, very dangerous....but
soooo hilarious at the time).
As a high school student,
music was one of the priorities in life. I would listen to Metallica
or Faith No More to get me pumped while driving to the beach to surf.
My foot would always get heavier on the accelerator as the waves came into
view and my favorite song was blasting out of the speakers in my mother's
car. Reggae tunes like Bob Marley, Steel Pulse and Black
Uhuru always brought my friends and I home slow and safe from a hard days
surfing or football practice.
Now, I enjoy listening
to Hawaiian music when I want to be mellow and take my time to get where
I am headed. This music relieves my tension and allows me to deal with
idiot drivers and bumper to bumper traffic in an extremely passive way.
However, I listen to Rap or Alternative music when I am in a hurry
to get somewhere; my adrenaline pumps, the music seems to make me
more aware of my driving behaviors. As for the future, I think the
trend speaks for itself. Fast and hard music when I am in a hurry
and slow, soft music when I am not. Maybe when I'm 60 years old I'll
listen to only slow music while driving :).
Introduction
This section contains
links which are associated (as closely as possible) with the subject of
music and driving. Under each link is a summary of the web site,
what it has to offer, and in what way it relates to the topic of music
and driving.
My Music "Joe Wein's detailed description of music and it's relation to him"
This site, found on with the use of the Excite search engine, was a section of Joe Wein's home page. This was the sixth site listed in a search for "driving and music." This part of Joe's Home page was labeled "My Favorite Music," much of which was Reggae. I was immediately attracted to the sites abstract which mentions Joe's love for Reggae music. I too, enjoy Reggae music and was curious to see how other's perceived the captivating music as well. This site offered links to other sites including "Bob Marley and The Wailers, Brasilian, and African music. Joe mentions that he was influenced by older Reggae music of the 70's by artists such as Bob Marley, Gregory Isaacs and Burning Spear. He also mentions his new found interest in African and Brasilian music as well. In the Bob Marley section Joe describes his deep connection with the reggae music. "This music had a magical effect on me. I had never heard anything like it before....Bob Marley and Rastafarian culture have had a lasting effect on me. Bob Marley has never just been music to me but a way of life."
Like Joe, I also enjoy Reggae music. The hypnotizing sound and hidden lyrical messages of promise are an inspiration to me. I believe this sort of music is perfect for those motorists who have little patience when on the roadways. Reggae's smooth, "skanking" sound allows one to unwind thus, preventing tension that could cause aggressive driving. This type of music has the same affect as Classical, Hawaiian
Hands
on Music Inc. "Sound Engineered for the driving experience. A
New Recording Category for the Auto
Environment."
This web site found
with the help of Excite search engine, consists of the new company Hands
on Music Inc. approach to create music especially for driving. It seems
this company has established an idea to enhance the music quality and sound
in the close quarters of the automobile. They have come up with what
they call "A new recording category for the auto environment." Although
it is unclear whether the company engineers a variety of music, the example
of their first product is a Jazz composition called "Driving Beverly Hills,"
which may also be purchased on this web page itself.
"DRIVING BEVERLY HILLS is designed
to give you the feel of the open road, on a drive from New York to Los
Angeles or just a spin to your local gas station.
It's music to make you look with excitement for what's around the
next turn, "says Hands On's Chuck Bennett, who
adds that this is the first in a projected series of recordings
specifically for the automotive environment."
I am somewhat confused
as to the details of this companies operations however; I believe
they intend to market music mixed by their staff in a specail way (whether
it be pop, rock, country or classical) to be of the best quality for the
enjoyment on a car stereo system. If this is so, I believe this would
surely enhance the effects of music on driving in a more positive manner.
Hands on Music Inc. could manufacture a sound that may eliminate aggressive
driving feelings through their innovative engineering ideas. By creating
a much more enjoyable driving atmosphere which calms the nerves and
brings about a happy emotional state. Driving may become a whole
new positive experience for many of us who dread the thought of the daily
commute.
Radio
K Music Forum
The Radio K Music Forum
is sort of like a chat area or newsgroup. The browser is allowed
to join a forum where other people have left responses to previous mail
listings, asked information about music or just expressed their pleasure
with the radio station. The operation of leaving a message is really
simple...one just has to scroll to the bottom of the web page, fill out
the form to post a page and that's it. Later, the message comes up
and people reply to you and you can later reply to them and so on.
I think this is a great idea for those people who would like to comment
on a song or issue that was brought up on the air when they were on their
way to work or something. One can go into more detailed discussions
with other listeners that agree or disagree with one's opinion.
Introduction
The following are summaries
of previous generation's reports with sections containing any reference
to music and driving.
Sheldon
Tawata's Report on "My Driving Personality Makeover Plan" G2
"The music that I try
to avoid is music with heavy, bashing drumming with loud and fast guitar
playing...any type of head banging, speed driven, angry heavy metal music
is not my music of choice for driving in traffic and probably driving in
general." Says Sheldon Tawata as he states the sort of music which does
not appeal to him while on the roadway. However; my personal view
is that some of this head banging music keeps my senses alert through the
act of making my adrenaline pump. This I believe, could also contribute
in some way in keeping one focused and on the defensive side of driving.
This sense of heightened awareness may prevent me from actually playing
a part in an accident. One may be more likely to be prepared for
a dangerous situation( swerving, changing lanes without checking first)
caused by another aggressive driver.
Sheldon Believes, "The music
I truly enjoy using when I'm at the wheel is songs from the Jane's Addiction
collection, Peter Gabriel's Last Temptation of Christ soundtrack, The Best
of the Gypsy Kings and Santana...It somewhat takes me away from the direct
realities of the traffic I'm experiencing without totally withdrawing from
the actual driving." Sheldon goes on to mention that he keeps
a collection of these various types of music handy in his car so that he
may select a track to fit his mood while driving which brings forth better
driving behavior qualities. I like his idea of keeping different
music available while driving. One could pop in a tape of Mozart after
a stressful day to reduce anxiety in traffic or simply throw in some Sublime
when feeling drowsy on a long late night drive. What a convenient
way of dealing with mixed emotions while behind the wheel.
Bruce
Nakada's Report on "My Driving Personality Makeover Plan" G3
During his driving
personality makeover, Bruce has found that the faster alternative music,
from a band called Offspring, makes him drive very fast. And while
listening to Hawaiian or Reggae music, Bruce's personality changes to one
of complete ease. He mentions " When I am in this "zone," there is
not one thing that could upset me. A driver could be tailgating me or cut
me off, but I would not get rattled." In my report on "The Affect
of Music on Drivers," it seems that most individuals share the same
feelings as Bruce Nakada in that fast music causes one to speed and be
aggressive where as slow music makes one calm and accepting of other normally
intolerant drivers.
Cheryl
Andaya's Report on "Managing a Quality Driving Circle: The Effort to Combat
Road Rage"
Cheryl expresses her
feeling of fear when her boyfriend isn't paying attention to the road and
is singing and talking to her while he drives. She goes on to explain
how this behavior prevents her boyfriend from knowing what's going on around
him. For example, Cheryl explains times she had to tell him to watch
out for the upcoming red light. I can totally identify with her boyfriend's
behavior, I too have done the same thing many times (singing or talking
to the passenger while behind the wheel). Although it is a very unsafe
habit there are times when we as motorists lose perspective of our responsibility
to be attentive.
Introduction
The following
summaries are from our class text "Challenging the Old Order," by
J. Peter Rothe and also
class discussions on the affects music
has on our abilities as motorists.
In chapter 3 "The Engineering of Safety and the Safety of Engineering" on page 46, The subject is road safety and the topic of noise goes as such. "Noise is defined as "unwanted sound." To describe noise, one has to measure the degree to which sound is bearable." In relation to music and how it might play a negative part in road safety, i believe the issue of loud music being played through modified automobile sound systems some years ago prompted laws which make it illegal to have a car stereo projecting sound farther than 20 feet away form the vehicle (If I recall correctly). I am almost certain that police can now issue citations to motorists playing their stereos too loud which causes "noise pollution". i believe this was a necessary step in maintaining peace in traffic because these "boom boxes" could be unsafe by causing distractions to other driver's, preventing motorist from hearing emergency vehicle sirens and prolonged exposure to such loud music could cause deafness.
As mentioned in class by Dr. James, mood change may be caused by the various music one listens to while driving. I can personally associate with this suggestion. When listening to hard rock music I tend to go faster while driving an automobile; the music makes my heart beat faster and influences my physical actions to drive at a higher rate of speed. I've noticed that the same is true for a lot of my friends that I ride with. Also, when I hear slower music being played on the radio such as Hawaiian or R&B I tend to take my time and I seem to have more patience with other driver's. It's as though the slower music has an effect on my emotions causing me to be much more relaxed and passive as I operate a vehicle.
In the section
"The World of Traffic It's Problems and Pleasures" on page 28, There is
a discussion on "rush hour" traffic. "Everyone wants to avoid, but
almost all of us end up in it ...how do we cope with it?" I believe
one way of relieving the stress of rush hour traffic could be through the
exposure to music. Slower Methodical music like Classical or Hawaiian
could be a soothing remedy for the stress brought upon a motorist by traffic
congestion. These types of music keep the motorist from becoming
extremely aggressive, short tempered and irritated. The music allows one
to drift off spiritually by this I mean it causes a sort of transpersonal
experience, one may mentally disconnect from the pressures that are present
while in a traffic jam.
Turner, M.L., Fernandez, J.E., and Nelson, K. The effect of music amplitude on the reaction to unexpected visual events. The Journal of General Psychology, Jan 1996, v123, n1, p51 (12).
Ballard, Mary E.,Coates, Steven. The Immediate Effects of Homicidal, Suicidal, and Nonviolent Heavy Metal and Rap Songs on the Moods of College Students. Youth & Society; v27 n2 p148-68 Dec 1995 .
Arnett, J. The Soundtrack of Recklessness: Musical Preferences among
Adolescents. Journal of Adolescents
Research, 1992, 7, 313-31.
Spinney, L. Pump down the volume. (the effect of music on driving) New
Scientist, July 19, 1997, v155,
n2091, p22 (1).
Ogata, S. Human EEG responses to classical music and simulated white noise: effects of musical loudness component on consciousness. Perceptual and Motor Skill, June 1995, v80, n3, p770 (12).
Iversen, Janet. The Effect of Music On The Personal Relevance of Lyrics. Psychology: A Journal of Human Behavior,V26 N2-3 P15-22 1989.
I enjoyed reading Mr.
Shintani's report for it was simple with no graphics and straight to
the point. His content was excellent in terms of detail. On
the other hand, I also enjoyed Grace
Lumbao's report for the appearance of her paper was livened with colors
that caught my attention. Her background which is layered with a
different array of colors is very attractive and surprisingly is not hard
on the eyes (in a reading sense that is). I usually don't like multi-colored
backgrounds because late night reading makes it difficult to focus on so
many colors. However, this doesn't happen when I read through Ms.
Lumabao's report.
My first suggestion
would be to tackle the references of any paper you do first. These
take the longest to find because such little information is listed in ERIC
or UNCOVER and a lot of
the topics are not related. For instance, Music and Driving
are not listed together but do appear as separate topics in the database.
Secondly, I would search the web for info next. While it is somewhat
easier than the first part suggested it still takes sometime in finding
articles which pertain to your report topic. For example, if
you type in Music and Driving you will notice that most of the information
is about car audio system solicitations or other sites that don't even
deal with the combination topic but have driving or music in the topic
(Musicians looking for band members who are able to play DRIVING bass sounds).
Other than the above mentioned the report is quite interesting and once
you get started you will be astonished at how much your personal experience
plays a part in the report construction.