Report #1 - Quality Driving Circles - Useful or Not?


By Raeder Kinney (G6)

See Instructions

Topical Index


What is a QDC?

Prior to beginning this report, I had no idea as to what QDC meant. After reading about it and after reviewing several student's generational reports dealing with QDC's, I gained a better understanding for it. A QDC is a group of people who come together to discuss traffic related topics. Topics include road rage, tailgating, speeding, and other various issues that drivers may experience while commuting on the highway. By sharing these experiences with one another, a QDC enables the participants to recognize their own inadequacies. Thus, recognizing a problem is the first step towards attaining a solution. (More about QDC)

[topical index]


Introduction: Why is there a need for QDC's?

Some interesting statistics:

--180 million drivers nationwide
--40,000 traffic fatalities per year in U.S.
--85% of all automobile crashes are due to human error 
--5 million major crashes per year in U.S.
--Cost (medical, auto repair, insurance, lost wages) 
	150 billion dollars per year
--1 pedestrian dies every 96 minutes in the U.S.
--1 of 3 teenagers will have an accident during their first
	 two years of driving
(More statistics)

As you can see from the figures that I have presented above, America has a serious driving problem. Every one of these statistics is shocking. I am twenty four years old, and I haven't been involved in a major traffic accident yet. After learning of these shocking statistics, I consider myself extremely lucky. By the time both my parents were my age, they were involved in major traffic accidents of their own. My brother was involved in a major crash when he was just seventeen! Something needs to be done in the United States so that the number of traffic accidents and traffic fatalities can be reduced. The statistics suggest that most of us will be involved in a major traffic accident sooner or later. Rather than ignore the nation's driving problem, as drivers, we need to improve on our driving skills.

Driving is a skill. Just like any other skill, it requires practice and repetition in order to become good. Over time and after countless hours behind the wheel, most of us become pretty good drivers. It becomes "second nature" to most of us. It becomes a habit. Once we learn the act of driving eg. turning the wheel, stepping on the brakes, flashing our indicators, sounding our horn, it's easy. After experience, many of us can drive for several seconds without ever looking at the road. It's as if we know what's going on around us without actually being able to see. Anyway, it's not these skills that need to be improved upon. It is our affective, cognitive and sensorimotor skills that need to be improved. These three skills are often referred to as ACS skills. ACS is an acronym for Affective-Cognitive-Sensorimotor. Let me give you a brief description of each of the three components. Affective skills refer to overcoming the resistance to change eg. allowing a passenger to make suggestions. Cognitive skills refer to the ability to rationalize and analyze situations. Sensorimotor skills refer to actual actions eg. waving, showing the "bird."

Virtually all drivers know how to flash their indicators and turn their steering wheel. On the other hand, there is great variation among drivers' ACS skills. It is possible for two drivers to react to the same situation in two very different ways. For example, if someone cuts you off, what do you do? Do you retaliate by speeding up and cutting him off, or do you let it slide? My initial reaction would probably be to do the former, but the smart thing is to do the latter. Retaliation gets you nowhere, especially on the road. As drivers, we need to improve on our ACS skills so that we don't retaliate. It sounds easy and straightforward, but it's not. It takes a lot of practice. Quality driving circles will help us to improve upon our ACS skills. Sharing our driving experiences in quality driving circles will enable us to realize our weaknesses and will provide us with an opportunity to discuss ways to improve on them.

[topical index]


Three of those in g5 who have conducted a QDC

Kimberly Oshiro-

In Kimberly's driving circle, she asked three people to be her "guinea pigs." She met with these three people on three separate occasions. Her sessions were not really planned out. Each one of Kimberly's sessions were pretty much impromptu and they lacked formal structure. Although Kimberly's sessions were informal, she did provide the members of her QDC with exercises to complete. She instructed the members of her group to perform some self-witnessing exercises. She instructed them to ask themselves some questions while driving:

  1. Do you follow the speed limit?
  2. Do you tailgate?
  3. Are you a courteous driver?
  4. What upsets you on the road?
  5. How do you calm yourself?

Kimberly also utilized a questionnaire that consisted of sixteen questions. Her questionnaire dealt with zones 4, 5, and 6 of Dr. Driving's chart of nine zones. Her questionnaire dealt mainly with self-control issues. Basically, by using the questionnaire, Kimberly could determine who in her QDC exhibits road rage. Kimberly also used her knowledge of traffic psychology to explain to the people in her QDC as to what exactly traffic psychology is and what road rage is.

It can't be determined whether or not Kimberly actually succeeded in her attempt to "change" her friends. To actually make a conclusion such as this, you would need to perform a long term, longitudinal study. Kimberly stated, "I can't force the people in my QDC to change. However, now at least their eyes are opened and ignorance is no longer an excuse. As long as they are aware that they are subjected to road rage, there is hope that they can change."

Michelle Wong-

Michelle Wong's QDC was very similar to Kimberly Oshiro's. Her QDC consisted of three people too. During the first of her three sessions, she explained the purpose of the QDC along with her goals and objectives. She had each member of her group evaluate themselves as drivers. She instructed them to write a week long journal in hopes that they would discover their weaknesses. During the second session, members of the QDC gave a summary of their journal report. They provided each other with suggestions. Kimberly made it clear to the members of her QDC that before fixing a problem, a problem must be recognized and identified. The third session was basically an evaluation session. It also provided another opportunity for group members to get together and discuss how their solutions were working.

It's difficult to determine whether or not Michelle's QDC was a success. Like Kimberly, Michelle allowed the members of her QDC to realize their weak points. Michelle made it clear to her QDC members that recognition is the first and perhaps the most important step in the therapeutic process.

Takeshi Hiraoka-

During session number one, Takeshi asked the members of his QDC a number of different questions. He wanted to get an idea as to how the members of his QDC viewed themselves as drivers. All three members of Takeshi's QDC perceived themselves as decent drivers. During the first session, Takeshi discovered that two members of his QDC were influenced by music while behind the wheel. Judging from the feedback he received from those two members, he assumed that a positive correlation exists between up-beat music and aggressive driving. The third and final session involved looking at reported improvements (if any) made by his group members.

Like Kimberly and Michelle, Takeshi also helped make the members of his QDC more aware and sensitive to their own thoughts and actions while driving. It's not possible for me to determine whether or not Takeshi succeeded at making the members of his QDC better, more aware drivers.

It is hard to judge whether or not Kimberly, Michelle and Takeshi succeeded in "changing" the driving habits of their friends. Three sessions is simply not sufficient. Bad driving habits that have developed over years of driving won't change overnight. Follow-up sessions would be ideal.

[topical index]


Running my own quality driving circle

When you get behind the wheel of an automobile, I feel that your driving reflects your mood. This is unfortunate. We all have bad days once in a while. Many times, we take our anxious, worried, hateful and sometimes violent emotions out on the road with us. This can be a real hazard. A "crooked" state of mind can sometimes result in offensive, senseless, impaired and down right dangerous driving. Let me give you an example which I'm sure each and every one of you can relate to. Last week, I got into an argument with my girlfriend. When I left home, I was pretty irate. I couldn't think straight. It just so happened that I had to go to work later that afternoon. Anyway, while driving to work, I must have been traveling at about 75 mph or so! The weird thing is, it didn't really affect me. I didn't care about the other drivers who were on the road. I continued to drive recklessly in total disregard for the safety of the others. I didn't really realize my recklessness until I ran a red light and was honked at! After hearing the horn, I finally realized the danger I was putting myself and the other drivers around me in.

Controlling your emotions is the key to better driving. If everyone on the road was happy, courteous, and safety conscious, our highways would probably be much safer. Quality Driving Circles are effective tools that can help drivers recognize their feelings, thoughts and actions while driving (ACS skills).

Meeting #1-

There were three members in my QDC. They included Harmony, Emmett and Jared. During our first meeting, I asked each one of them to evaluate themselves as drivers. I asked them to evaluate themselves in regards to things like:

  1. driver courtesy
  2. patience in traffic
  3. whether or not they follow the speed limit
  4. how they react to offensive drivers

Both Harmony and Emmett felt as though they were pretty good drivers. Harmony stated, "I've been driving for eight years, what else is there to know?" Emmett stated, "Everyone always seems to get in my way." Jared didn't really have a reaction to my questions. But, he later stated that he was a pretty decent driver. I asked the members of my QDC to perform a simple self-witnessing exercise. They all agreed to take a tape recorder in the car with them and record the going's on.

Meeting #2-

The second meeting was spent listening to the tapes that I instructed them to use. Interestingly, none of them verbally exhibited any road rage whatsoever. I found only singing and mumbling. After asking each of them about their self-witnessing experience, they said that it was worthwhile. I knew that this data was inaccurate. Perhaps their responses were biased because of the fact that they knew their responses were being recorded. I decided to take a different approach. After meeting number two, I contacted the mothers of my QDC members. I asked them if it would be possible to take some notes regarding their driving experiences with their son or daughter. This method required them to be in the car with their son or daughter. This method was a little "out of the way," but it was the only way I could think of to obtain unbiased results.

Meeting #3-

I allowed three days to go by before holding the third session. During the third session, I presented my three friends with the notes that were given to me by their mothers. They were totally shocked. I wasn't. I received the results I was looking for. The mothers reported speeding. Jared's mom observed him traveling 70 mph on Farrington Highway! That wasn't the worst of it. Emmett's mom reported some violent behavior. While overtaking a slow traveling car, Emmett reportedly made an attempt to spit on it! Harmony wasn't as brilliant a driver as she thought either. According to her mom, she tailgated a slow driver for approximately four miles!

Not only was this exercise fun, it made the three of them realize what kind of drivers they actually were. At the end of our third meeting, I again asked them what kind of drivers they perceived themselves as. None of them had the same answer. They all agreed that they needed to improve on their driving. This exercise made my friends more sensitive drivers. Recognizing their individual problems was easy. Actually practicing proper driver etiquette takes a lot of time and practice. You can't expect to change bad driving behavior overnight. But, you can quickly make drivers more sensitive and aware of their attitudes before they get behind the wheel.

[topical index]


Promotion of quality driving circles

There are many ways to promote QDC's. QDC's can be advertised via television, radio and billboards. By making the general public aware of QDC's, perhaps many more people will be interested in becoming a part of them.

Money is a major problem with the promotion of QDC's. Because most people deny the fact that they have a driving problem, they feel that promoting QDC's is unnecessary and a waste of money. The statistics that I mentioned earlier speak for themselves. A federal, state or city funded QDC program would be beneficial for us all.

Prior to conducting my own QDC, none of the members of my QDC knew what a QDC was. Public awareness is very important. As I stated earlier, QDC's can be advertised via television, radio and billboard. Also, information about QDC's can be found on the internet. Because of the fact that millions of people have access to the internet, information regarding QDC's can be found quickly and easily.

[topical index]


Activities like quality driving circles that are now going on among citizen groups

MADD, SADD and AA are all similar to QDC's. They all attempt to make people aware and more sensitive to a problem. In MADD, SADD and AA, alcohol abuse is the problem. In the case of QDC's, it's a driving/attitude problem.

[topical index]


The implications for driver education, licensing and insurance discounts

I am a motorcycle rider. Prior to getting my motorcycle license, I took a Motorcycle Safety Course. By taking the class, my insurance premium was reduced by fifteen percent. The same type of thing should be done with QDC's. Lower insurance costs would possibly give drivers the incentive to participate in a safety class. Perhaps the city should require all people applying for a drivers license to enroll in QDC's.

Many of us (including myself) should not have been issued a drivers license. It's easy to learn how to operate an automobile. Most of us can pick up on it very quickly. The hard part deals with the psychological aspect of driving. For instance, how do we react when confronted with a stressful situation while driving? The handbook doesn't teach you that. We need to learn the proper ACS skills ahead of time.

Prior to being issued a drivers license, it is my opinion that all prospective teenage drivers should be required to enroll in programs that teach them proper ACS skills.

[topical index]


Promotion of QDC's by future generations

With our country's growing population, there will be a large increase in the number of drivers on the road. We need to make the younger generation aware of the driving problem. We need to inform them ahead of time as to what they should expect once they begin driving. ACS skills should be incorporated into the everyday education process. Teaching them these skills will make them more sensitive and aware of the fact that their actions reflect their attitudes.

Programs involving parents should also be promoted. Programs that inform parents about QDC's and ACS skills will not only benefit them, but also the kids. Parental reinforcement of ACS skills will be beneficial and very worthwhile.

[topical index]


My Exploration of the Generational Curriculum Labyrinth | My Home Page | My Report 1 on: Quality Driving Circles-Useful or Not? | My Report 2 on: The Speed Limit Debate - How Do I Stand? | My Newsgroups Report | My Bookmarks File | My Icons File | Our G6 Class Home Page | Dr. Leon James Home Page

e-mail me