You are pretty, today.
Thank you.
Get lost!
How dare you!
Go home! I will not! (Why should I?)
etc.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I believe I promise
I know I state
I doubt
I argue
I suspect
I name
propositionalizing
or
I expect
I define
thinking verbs
I recall
I remember
I wonder
I hope
I anticipate
both of these sets are container
words
these are non-performatives
these are performatives
Question- Can you
find a syntactic semantic or other criterion to differentiate between them?
IF + predication THEN +
I can't say why he doesn't get it.
I can't say declarative description.
He doesn't get it presupposed decryption.
"He doesn't get it because..." I can't complete the predication.
Why is this so?
Predicate. This is so. / right / good
Identifying. This is it / the right one / good one.
Location. This comes before that / here instead of there
Reason. This is so because it comes first.
If this is so than it comes here before it goes there.
Assertion Types Zone
W Predicating X is Y
ASTRO
Y Classifying X/Y
ETHNO
G Modifying X.Y
SOCIO
Bl Subjectifying
DRAMATIZING
Br Objectifying
SUBTLE
Bk Actualizing
PERSONAL
I can't say CONSEQUENTLY, he doesn't get it.
BUT THEN,
AND ALSO,
MOREOVER,
HOWEVER,
NEVERTHELESS,
I can't say, BUT he doesn't get it.
I can't say WHY he doesn't get it.
I can't say THAT he doesn't get it.
I can't say BECAUSE he doesn't get it.
SINCE
INASMUCH
I can't say, THOUGH he doesn't get it.
I can't say, FEELING THAT he doesn't get it.
I can't say, AND FURTHER, he doesn't get it.
I can't say, AND YET he doesn't get it.
I can't say. He doesn't get it.
1. When a person says
" I am right" - the implication is that
his claim can be justified by some reasons:
"X is Y because a, b, c "
2. "Wrong reasons" means that a, b, c do not satisfy the logical
implication of because.
3. "You are right for the wrong reasons" means that:
X is Y is true (as opposed to X is not Y or X is Z) and
X is Y because d,e,f, (d, e, f, rather than a, b, c)
4. Also, there is the implication that (i) the person is
unaware of (2) and (3) and (ii) that X is Y demonstration,
e.g. Psychology is useful because it's scientific approach
enables it to help people.
Oppenheimer once said: "The practical usefulness of our
professions gives us the impression that we are right for
the
wrong reasons, and that our true nature is very different
form our public presence.
That is, we are right the fact that Psychology is useful
in its help of people but not a science ( but presumably
for other reasons).
In
Lyons, 1968 paper (APA)
|
|
|
|